Showing posts with label innocence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label innocence. Show all posts

Monday, August 6, 2007

GA Supreme Court Will Hear Troy Davis' Case; Original Jurors Urge New Trial

On Friday, the Georgia Supreme Court agreed to hear the appeal of Troy Davis, including new evidence of police coercion that undermines the eyewitness testimony that was the primary basis of his conviction.

Now, four jurors from Mr. Davis' original trial have come forward urging clemency and a new trial, in light of this new evidence that has come to public attention. Knowing what she knows now, one juror said that if Mr. Davis is executed, it will "haunt her until her own death." That juror and three others submitted sworn statements to the Georgia Board of Pardons and Paroles, urging them to avert this injustice.



Read more :: Permalink

Monday, July 23, 2007

Two New Studies Conclude: Faulty IDs Caused "Thousands" Of Wrongful Convictions

The New York Times reported this weekend that two new studies have looked closely at the wrongful conviction epidemic, and have concluded that there are literally thousands of people serving sentences in prison for crimes they did not commit.

The first, "Judging Innocence", is soon-to-be-published in the Columbia Law Review, conducted by University of Virginia Professor Brandon Garrett. Professor Garrett's study systematically examined all of the DNA exonerations and concluded that "the leading cause of the wrongful convictions was erroneous identification by eyewitnesses, which occurred 79 percent of the time. In a quarter of the cases, such testimony was the only direct evidence against the defendant." Other leading causes of wrongful convictions were faulty forensic evidence, unreliable snithc testimony and false confessions.

As the Times reports, Professor Garrett's study also "strongly suggests . . . that there are thousands of people serving long sentences for crimes they did not commit but who have no hope that DNA can clear them." This suggestion is based on the fact that so many DNA exonerations have occurred despite the fact that DNA evidence onlly exists in a small subset of cases.

The second forthcoming study, by Professors Samuel Gross at Michigan Law School and Barbara O'Brien of Michigan State, reached similar conclusions. Specifically, the Michigan study concluded:

"The main thing we can safely conclude from exonerations is that there are many other false convictions that we have not discovered," the Michigan study said. "In addition, a couple of strong demographic patterns appear to be reliable:

Black men accused of raping white women face a greater
risk of false conviction than other rape defendants; and young suspects, those under 18, are at greater risk of false confession than other suspects."

One other important point from the studies: "The courts performed miserably in ferreting out the innocent." Among other things, that really needs to change, and reforming ID procedures is one way to make it happen.



Read more :: Permalink

Friday, July 20, 2007

In the Pope's Own Words

We managed to obtain a copy of the Pope's letter (PDF) to Georgia Governor Sonny Perdue, calling for the commutation of Troy Davis' death sentence, in light of "strong claims of innocence," including now-recanted eyewitness testimony that appears to have resulted from police coercion.

More from the letter:

This particular case is all the more disturbing inasmuch as the public record indicates that most of the "witnesses" have recanted their testimony, alleging that their statements were coerced; Mr. Davis' conviction was not based on any physical evidence and the murder weapon was never found. While I am certain that these facts have been presented to you, I reiterate them so as to underscore that this is a case which merits very special consideration. It is deeply troubling taht the State of Georgia might proceed with this execution, given the lack of evidence and the strong claims of innocence in this particular case.

Read it for yourself. Click below.



Read more :: Permalink

The POPE Calls on Georgia to Spare Troy Davis


The Pope himself has formally called on the state of Georgia to spare Troy Davis from his death sentence.

The Vatican delivered a letter to Governor Sonny Perdue on Monday, the same day Mr. Davis's stay was granted.



"In the name of Pope Benedict XVI, I am respectfully asking you to commute Troy's sentence to life in prison without parole," wrote Monsignor Martin Krebs, the office's charge d'affaires.

Meanwhile, the Board of Pardons and Parole is considering the new evidence presented to it, and in their own words:
Scheree Lipscomb, a spokeswoman for the board, said it has received thousands of letters from Davis supporters, including U.S. Rep. John Lewis, a civil rights icon, and it will treat the pope's letter like all others. She said the board is aware of the letters, but its responsibility is to review the facts in the case.

Hopefully they will consider the fact that the Pope and everyone outside of the Georgia DA's office agrees that refusing to commute Mr. Davis's sentence would be a serious miscarriage of justice.



Read more :: Permalink

Monday, July 16, 2007

Troy Davis Granted 90-Day Stay

Great news: Troy Davis was just granted a 90-day stay of his death sentence, averting his execution scheduled for tomorrow night. The Pardon and Parole Board reached their decision to stay the execution after less than an hour of deliberation. Hopefully a more sensible solution will be reached over the next months and Mr. Davis can, for the first time, exercise his right to a fair trial.

More coverage at MSNBC and the Washington Post.

UPDATE: Press Release from the Parole and Pardon Board is here, and the order granting the stay is here (PDF). The order states, among other things, that:

The members of the Georgia Board of Pardons and Paroles will not allow an execution to proceed in this State unless and until it is convinced that there is no doubt as to the guilt of the accused.


For the record, that makes the Georgia standard for execution a higher standard, even, then beyond a reasonable doubt.



Read more :: Permalink

Will Georgia kill an innocent man tomorrow night?

More press coverage of the Troy Davis, the day before his scheduled execution.

Time Magazine: Will Georgia kill an innocent man?

And the Atlanta Journal Constitution, with a transcript of Congressman John Lewis's testimony at the Parole and Pardon Board hearing this morning, which starts off:

Good morning, Chairperson Hunt and members of the State Board of Pardons and Paroles.

It is a privilege to address you today, and I want to thank you for hearing me. I will not speak long, because what I have to say is very simple. I do not know Troy Anthony Davis. I do not know if he is guilty of the charges of which he has been convicted. But I do know that nobody should be put to death based on the evidence we now have in this case.

Evidence that is dramatically different from what the jury heard. Evidence that I understand no court has ever considered, for technical reasons that have nothing to do with the truth.


And from the Guardian: Death of an Innocent, Georgia Style

Mr. Davis's website and how you can help here.



Read more :: Permalink

Sunday, July 15, 2007

Update and Press Coverage of Troy Davis Case

AP has picked up the story of Troy Davis, the Georgia man on death row for a murder he maintains he did not commit. His lawyers filed a motion last week seeking a new trial, based on sworn affidavits by witnesses from the 1991 trial who now say they lied due to police coercion when they testified against Mr. Davis. The motion was denied, and defense lawyer Jason Ewart planned to appeal that ruling Friday night. A clemency hearing is set for Monday morning, before the GA Board of Pardons and Paroles.

More Georgia press coverage here. Click here to send a letter to the GA Board of Pardons and Paroles to urge them to stay Mr. Troy's execution, scheduled for Tuesday night.



Read more :: Permalink

Tuesday, June 5, 2007

New Dallas DA Comes in Swinging -- At Bad ID Procedures

As reported over at Grits for Breakfast and at the New York Times, the new Dallas District Attorney -- a career defense attorney until his election to DA in November -- has some new ideas about prosecuting crime. This shouldn't seem novel, but in Craig Watkins' own words, "I lock them up if they're guilty." But against the backdrop of 13 DNA exonerations in the last six years under the old leadership in Dallas County alone, a focus on prosecuting the guilty comes as a welcome change.

Among the changes Mr. Watkins has already brought is a dramatic reform to police lineup procedures, namely the use of double-blind procedures, where the person administering the lineup is unaware of the identity of the suspect. Studies like the Hennepin County Blind-Sequential Pilot Project (PDF) have generated promising results, suggesting that the use of blind procedures can play a key role in reducing the number of innocent people selected from police lineups.

In other fronts in Mr. Watkins' attack on what he terms the "conviction-at-all-costs" mentality of his predecessors, the new DA has put an end to the practice of destroying files in death penalty cases following convictions, and has partnered with the Innocence Project of Texas to review 400 new cases for possible wrongful convictions. He is also taking steps to educate prisoners, and provide drug rehab in custody.

To his critics -- who Watkins says "are just waiting for me to make a mistake" -- he says: "It doesn't make any difference. Let them be on the wrong side of history."



Read more :: Permalink

Monday, April 30, 2007

WSJ editorial & trial errors

One more thought about the WSJ editorial. Just as troubling as the argument that there is insufficient data that wrongful convictions are a problem is the assertion, slipped into the WSJ piece, that “trial errors” have little or no causal connection to a just or unjust outcome of a criminal trial -- as if jurors’ determinations of guilt can be divorced from how the evidence is presented (or excluded) at a trial.

The WSJ editorial states that:

The [innocence] mythmakers also directly conflate trial error rates with wrongful conviction rates. Studies showing astonishingly high error rates in capital trials have very little to do with the question of the rate at which innocent people are being convicted. I can't remember a single trial over which I have presided -- including dozens of homicides -- in which, looking back, I didn't make at least one error in ruling on objections. It is a giant leap from an erroneous trial ruling to reversible error, and another giant leap from reversible error to actual innocence.
The author is correct that, these days, there is a disconnect between an erroneous trial ruling and reversible error, but that’s only because, these days, what our justice system is willing to dismiss as “harmless” covers a shocking breadth of mistakes and misconduct by judges, prosecutors and defense lawyers, and the whole harmless error analysis itself is flawed by artificially examining errors in isolation, without acknowledging that one mistaken ruling can change the landscape of a trial.


As for the connection between the strictly circumscribed set of errors we deem “reversible” and actual innocence, the author seems to miss the point, that we reverse convictions with these errors because we no longer have confidence that the verdict has a legitimate foundation -- in other words, in these cases we think that guilt has not been proven beyond a reasonable doubt, leaving open a real possibility that the defendant is actually innocent.



The author has apparent confidence in the outcomes of the cases over which he presided. But the recollections of a single trial judge about the lack of connection between his erroneous rulings and wrongful convictions hardly constitutes reliable data that proves that the status quo works just fine. I imagine that that the judges who presided over the trials of the now 200 exonerees were also quite confident in the correctness of the outcomes in those cases, but that’s not terribly reassuring.



Think, for example, of the case of exoneree Kirk Bloodsworth, who was sentenced to two life terms in prison based on the positive identifications of five eyewitnesses and served eight years in prison before he was proven innocent by DNA evidence. At his first trial, he unsuccessfully tried to present testimony from an expert in the field of eyewitness perception and memory to testify about some of the factors that make eyewitness identifications unreliable. On appeal, the reviewing court said that the trial court’s ruling excluding this critical testimony wasn’t even error -- much less harmless error.



Thus, in the Bloodsworth case, a legal ruling that wasn't even deemed erroneous by an appellate court (though it almost certainly was erroneous under any fair application of expert law -- but that's an entirely separate story), demonstrably helped to produce a wrongful conviction. Given that even such "correct" rulings can lead to miscarriages of justice, its not a giant leap to suggest that erroneous rulings can have this effect and its even less of a leap to attribute miscarriages of justice to reversible errors. In today's judicial system, where the standard of reversible error is so high, and where judges make serious errors in a significant percentage of trials, the outcomes of the proceedings infected by these serious error are also likely to be erroneous a significant portion of the time.


Certainly its a lot more of stretch to say, as the WSJ editorial does, that in a system where errors by judges are common (as even the author admits), jurors rarely if ever get it wrong when they are forced to decide the fundamental question put to them – guilty or not guilty – based on a flawed presentation of the evidence. That's contrary to common sense and human nature, as the DNA exonerations have demonstrated.



Read more :: Permalink

Friday, April 27, 2007

Stages of Denial: The Numbers Are On Our Side Too

As Ben's post shows, many in the criminal justice process remain in the denial stage with respect to wrongful convictions. Before DNA, those same people repeatedly would say, with confidence, that innocent people were NEVER convicted in our criminal justice system. In the pre-DNA era, they disdainfully dismissed works like the Radelet study -- a pre-DNA study that concluded that 23 innocent capital defendants had been executed in the past 85 years -- pointing to its supposed flaws such as its reliance on "one-sided" materials like newspaper articles.

Of course, any pre-DNA attempt to demonstrate innocence, particularly post-humously and often years after-the-fact, would be subject to criticism by those who simply wanted to prolong the debate. Before DNA, it was simply impossible to definitively prove or disprove whether the criminal justice system wrongfully convicted people. If they wanted to, skeptics could continue to deny forever that such miscarriages of justice ever occurred, pointing to various "flaws" in exoneration cases that seemed to fairly definitively establish a miscarriage of justice.

Then the DNA exonerations came. And it was good. But not enough for the skeptics. At that point, it obviously became impossible for any rational person to deny that the criminal justice system sometimes convicted the wrong person. But when reformers then began to demand that the system take simple steps to fix what was now an identified and undeniable problem -- by, for example, reforming demonstrable problems in eyewitness identification procedures -- the skeptics began to question the scope of the problem, now demanding that reformers not only demonstrate the existence of the problem and its causes, but also its precise scope.

In other words, the skeptics once again wanted to prolong the debate by shifting it to even more unprovable territory. But even so, if it's numbers they want, it's numbers they'll get. Reformers are not afraid of the numbers because, while we'll never be able to establish precise error rates in the absence of some reliable measure of ground truth in every case, the numbers we do have themselves give rise to grave cause for alarm.

What numbers am I talking about? At the outset, its important to make clear that, for comparison purposes, we should look only at the number of criminal trials the system conducts, not the number of criminal convictions. Wrongful convictions are almost always convictions that occur following a trial, and thus the important question is how many of these trial verdicts are erroneous. Any attempt to include guilty plea convictions in the mix is simply an attempt to unfairly and artificially dilute the rate of wrongful convictions.

So the real question is how often factfinders convict people who claim at trial that they are innocent. The DNA exonerations themselves suggest that the scope of the problem is quite substantial. Why? Because testable DNA is available in only a small fraction of criminal cases -- the case must involve an item where the presence of absence of DNA is dispositive, which is not a common scenario -- and even in such cases, the physical evidence has often been destroyed before it could ever be tested. It's also not as though resources exist to routinely conduct testing in every eligible case or that there are lawyers who are available to take the results of those tests and to advocate for their clients on that basis. Given that the pool of cases in which DNA exonerations is possible is very small, the fact that the Innocence Project has managed to definitively exonerate 200 people from around the country suggests that the scope of the problem is substantial. Yes, it's "only" 200 people -- so far -- but its 200 people from the small group from which DNA testing could still be conducted and for which resources existed and trained, skilled lawyers were able to present the results to a court or the prosecutor.

The fact that so many innocent people have come to light under such circumstances tells us that we would inevitably get a lot more exonerations if we could establish ground truth in every case. Unfortunately, there is currently no way to do so.

But does that mean that we can only extrapolate an error rate from the exoneration numbers alone? No, we have at least two other numbers that provide us with some idea of the wrongful rate.

First, in Virginia, law enforcement authorities recently discovered a host of biological evidence from cases tried in the 1970's and 1980's. Before ordering DNA testing on all the evidence, Gov. Mark Warner ordered scientists to conduct DNA testing on a small, randomly selected percentage of sexual assault cases tried between 1973 and 1988 to determine if a more widespread DNA testing of the hundreds of convictions obtained during that time would be warranted. Of the 31 cases reviewed, two exonerations occurred. In other words, 6 percent of the randomly sampled cases tested resulted in exonerations. Predictably, both Virginia exonerations involved convictions that relied heavily on eyewitness testimony. See Michael D. Shear and Jamie Stockwell, DNA Tests Exonerate 2 Former Prisoners, WASH. POST., December 15, 2005, at A01.

Sure, its a small sample size. But its a random sample too, and if the criminal justice system has an error rate that is anything approaching 6% of the overall cases, the consequences are truly staggering. It would mean there are thousands of innocent folks sitting in jail around the country.

Second, we know that the FBI conducts DNA testing in a number of cases where criminal charges have already been filed (often based on eyewitness testimony), and that such testing often exculpates suspects. Unfortunately, the FBI has never made public how often DNA testing exonerates wrongly accused suspects. We have unofficially heard that the exoneration rate in such cases runs as high as 25%. Assuming that error rate is anywhere near accurate, and assuming that a similar error rate exists in cases where DNA can never rule out the suspect's guilt, such numbers would provide powerful (and quite frightening) evidence about the scope of the wrongful conviction problem in the criminal justice system.

On the question of numbers, as Ben points out, the precise ratio of wrongful convictions one is willing to tolerate ultimately boils down to a question of morality. Some agree with Ben Franklin and the Framers of the Constitution (as we do) about the importance of keeping the innocent out of jail, while others agree with the Former Chief of the Soviet Secret Police about the importance of locking up a lot innocent bystanders in an effort to get all the guilty culprits. Do you want to live in a free society that is strong enough to protect the innocent by providing meaningful civil rights and criminal justice protections for all its citizens, or do you want to live in a society that is so petrified by fear that it needlessly sacrifices the lives of innocent persons in order to obtain a "margin of safety" for those who are lucky enough not to be swept up in the net?


Whatever your moral position on this issue, its becoming clearer and clearer that our criminal justice system gets it wrong far too often. In the face of that reality, you can bury your head in the sand, or you can do something about it. We've chosen the latter course.



Read more :: Permalink

The Innocence Myth?

The Wall Street Journal just published an editorial (of which they were generous enough to provide a free preview) by the Honorable Morris B. Hoffman, a Colorado District Judge, in which Judge Hoffman audaciously labels "innocence" a myth -- in the specific context of the great work of organizations like the Innocence Project, and others working to undo wrongful convictions and reduce their future occurrence.

The author makes a veiled reference to "one of those innocence projects," to kick things off:

The director of one of those innocence projects said in a 2002 magazine interview that "we as a nation" would rather have the criminal justice system convict 10 innocent people than let one guilty person go free, inverting the famous Blackstone Ratio. Today, that project's Web site lists as one of its missions the duty to educate the public about the "prevalence" of wrongful convictions.

I can't say what the nation thinks, but one doesn't have to be in this business for long to begin to believe it. Prosecutors and police forces fight tooth and nail against reforms that are carefully tailored to employ scientific principles proven to reduce the likelihood that innocent people will end up in prison, and policymakers in many cases end up siding with them.

Maybe this is the crux of the issue. Ben Franklin said in 1780: "That it is better 100 guilty Persons should escape than that one innocent Person should suffer, is a maxim that has been long and generally approved" (a more zealous take on what is known as the "Blackstone ratio"). A century later, Feliks Dzerzhinksy (founder of the Soviet secret police) stood Ben Franklin's "long approved" maxim on its head, proclaiming it "better to execute ten innocent men than to leave one guilty man alive." Maybe what we are observing is two conflicting views of the world -- and the value of human liberty -- fundamentally at odds.

When you can't convince law enforcement agencies to implement simple measures like double-blind lineup procedures designed to minimize the effects of their suspicion on witness choices, it starts to look like the Feliks Dzerzhinskys of the world are winning the day. That's not to say that progress isn't being made, but there are many rivers left to cross.

But back to this WSJ article. Hoffman goes on to inquire about the actual rate of innocence. Maybe, after all, these "innocence advocates" and the "liturgies that have grown up around them" (!) are worshipping a false idol, the WSJ author/judge implies. Apparently out to get these pesky innocence proselytizers, who "are strangely silent when it comes to that question" of the actual innocence rate, Hoffman tries to redirect the dialogue to a question of the error rate, which is what really matters "in imperfect complex systems." Hoffman appears to imply that if the "error rate" -- that is, the rate at which innocent people are incarcerated and in some cases, possibly executed -- is within an acceptable range, then the innocence projects -- which he belittles as both "mythmakers" and "innocence merchants" -- are in a tizzy over nothing.

But this brings us back to the Blackstone ratio, and a fundamental clash of worldviews that I think is at the heart of this disagreement. 200 innocent people incarcerated for a combined total of 2,475 years in prison is not an "acceptable error rate," no matter the ratio of wrongfully convicted to "rightfully" convicted. And obviously the work of the Cardozo Innocence Project, and the battalions of others committed to the same cause, do not represent the entirety of the problem. Other innocents remain in prison, and new innocents continue to be put in prison.

The "mythmakers" are silent on the question of the "actual innocence rate" because the problem of innocent people being deprived of their liberty is not a statistical problem; it is a moral problem. This is exactly what Ben Franklin meant when he said that "it is better 100 guilty Persons should escape than that one innocent Person should suffer": human liberty is not reducible to a mundane statistical formulation. Innocence advocates are silent on the question of the actual innocence rate not because they fear the answer, but because it is fundamentally the wrong question.



Read more :: Permalink

Monday, April 2, 2007

One, Two, Three: DNA Exoneration Of Anthony J. Capozzi

The exoneration of Anthony Capozzi for a crime in Buffalo is just the latest in a long string of DNA exonerations for convictions based primarily on eyewitness testimony. In Mr. Capozzi's case, three eyewitnesses confidently identified him at trial as the rapist.

The quote highlighted by Talk Left is the most telling part of the story:

“Maybe one’s wrong, maybe two are wrong, but jurors sit there and say how can three people possibly be wrong?” he said. “They were all so positive it was
him.”

But there is another quote that struck me too. At the time of his trial, Mr. Capozzi sent a warning out to the people in Buffalo:
I said women in Buffalo shouldn't take comfort in the fact that Anthony Capozzi was convicted of these crimes," he said. "He didn’t do them. I suggest that you not run in Delaware Park alone. Because the person who did these is still out there.

Twenty-two years in prison for a crime he did not commit. Plus no increase in public safety as the real culprit remains free. The cost of mistaken eyewitness testimony.



Read more :: Permalink

Friday, March 2, 2007

Lineup Waivers?

More from Munsterberg -- Saul Kassin's plenary talk this afternoon chronicled a collection of DNA exonerations, as well as one suspected false conviction with post-conviction proceedings still in progress, a man named Marty Tankleff. Seventeen years ago, while in his last year of high school, Tankleff awoke in his house to find all the lights on, his mother brutally murdered, and his father bludgeoned to within inches of his life. Following a collection of blatant lies by police regarding fabricated evidence -- including a fabricated finger-pointing by his dying father -- Tankleff confessed, citing his inability to contradict his father, and remains in prison 17 years later for a crime he very likely did not commit.

It also turns out that in Louisville, Kentucky, there is a little-known practice called the voluntary lineup waiver, which is to say that a suspect can waive his right to be placed into a lineup and appear for a show-up in front of a witness. As it turns out, innocent people are the only ones who take advantage of this particular option, based on the (often false) belief that the rigors of the criminal justice system will bring about the truth, and that they do not require the same protections against suggestive police procedures. It also turns out that many such innocents end up in prison as a result.



Read more :: Permalink

Thursday, March 1, 2007

Live from Munsterberg

A quick report from Day 1 of "Off the Witness Stand," which is off to a great start. Kicking things off was a panel comprised of Janet Reno, Jim Doyle, Jeremy Travis, and Hon. John Martin.

Jim Doyle opened up with his characterization of this conference as a sort of "do-over" of the historic dialogue between Hugo Munsterberg and John Henry Wigmore, which scared Munsterberg and other social scientists away from the courts for most of the last century, on the grounds that more data and more research were necessary before the social sciences were ready for the rigors of a well-crafted cross-examination. Now, the studies have been done, the science is in, and Reno and others see this conference as an opportunity to make new efforts at bringing science and the law more closely into alignment.

Jeremy Travis, former director of the National Institute of Justice, told the story of receiving a call from Janet Reno when she was the US Attorney General under Clinton. She was reading an article in the Washington Post about a man who had just been released from prison after 10 years of wrongful conviction, which was overturned by way DNA test results that cleared him from involvement. That story led Ms. Reno to investigate how many other cases there were like this one, and then to root out the causes. That investigation led to the study published as "Convicted by Juries, Exonerated by Science," (PDF) which told the tale of 26 DNA exonerees, almost all of whom had been convicted based on faulty eyewitness testimony and, ultimately, a failure of science to inform the criminal justice system.

More to come from John Jay in the days ahead.



Read more :: Permalink