Showing posts with label NIJ Report. Show all posts
Showing posts with label NIJ Report. Show all posts

Thursday, March 29, 2007

Onward from LeGrand

Decisions like LeGrand (PDF), and the Third Circuit's superb decision last summer in United States v. Brownlee (PDF), 454 F.3d 131 (3d Cir. 2006), suggest that courts are starting to warm up to the idea that the social science research can help limit the role mistaken eyewitness testimony has played in creating wrongful convictions. I think it's likely that these cases will hasten the day when expert testimony of this sort is routine in cases that rely primarily on eyewitness testimony. I also think this is important: For too long, the judicial system has virtually ignored this important research. Courts ignore science at their peril.

But it is also not enough. There are not enough experts, there never will be enough experts, and expert testimony will often be limited even in cases where it does occur. And even if expert testimony perfectly assesses the identification and its reliability (or unreliability), that will still not always be enough to counteract a witness who genuinely but mistakenly looks across the courtroom and says: "That's him! I'll never forget that face as long as I live."

So where else do we go from here? Quite apart from expert testimony, we need to improve ways of selecting, educating and instructing jurors throughout the trial. The legal system also can reform itself in other ways. Gary Wells, for example, has suggested that the legal system should prevent "lineup jeopardy" (the risk of mistakenly being accused of a crime simply by virtue of being placed in a lineup) by limiting the ability of police to place someone in a lineup or photo spread -- through a requirement that police independently make some showing of individualized suspicion probable cause (PDF) before an identification procedure occurs.

But probably the most important piece of the reform puzzle will occur outside the courtroom, since it involves preventing eyewitness evidence from becoming unnecessarily "tainted" BEFORE it makes its way into court. That is, by adopting police procedures that prevent misidentifications from occurring at all, rather than trying to blunt or diminish their effect afterwards.

The legal system can do a lot to shape the procedures police use to handle eyewitness evidence, and we now know a lot about which police identification procedures work and which do not. A lot of what we know has even been compiled into guidelines (PDF) by the Department of Justice. Some police departments will choose to follow them on their own, and will provide sufficient training so that officers can professionally handle eyewitness evidence in every case (see, e.g., Hennepin County, Minnesota, and Northampton, Massachusetts (PDF)). The more police that adopt this sort of reform on their own the better because other solutions are more complicated and will take more time.

But inevitably some jurisdictions will lag behind and resist. In those jurisdictions, some form of mandate will be required. Some states will go the legislative route, as West Virginia, Maryland, Virginia and others have done. Others will go the executive branch route, as New Jersey has done. And still other states will require the judicial route, with courts forcing police to change by excluding eyewitness evidence infected by shoddy and outdated police practices.

Some have said that reforms like these cannot be legislated or directed by courts; police need to want to change their conduct before reforms can take hold. Many reform-minded police officers would say otherwise. A good example has arisen in the debate involving recorded interrogations. Many police departments and officers vigorously opposed recording interrogations, usually on the ground that it would deter statements. Our police in Washington D.C. said the same thing when they fought recording legislation. But now that the results are in, police I have spoken with (including police here) love recording interrogations because it produces evidence they can be confident in -- confident in their own minds that any confession is reliable and confident that the evidence will hold up to any challenge in court when scrutinized by judges, lawyers and jurors.

The same thing will eventually happen with eyewitness procedures -- once the bias in favor the status quo is broken, police will see how reformed eyewitness procedures are just another example of how simple, smart police reform can make the system tougher, smarter and fairer for everyone involved.

That's where we're headed. It's just a matter of time.



Read more :: Permalink

Thursday, March 1, 2007

Live from Munsterberg

A quick report from Day 1 of "Off the Witness Stand," which is off to a great start. Kicking things off was a panel comprised of Janet Reno, Jim Doyle, Jeremy Travis, and Hon. John Martin.

Jim Doyle opened up with his characterization of this conference as a sort of "do-over" of the historic dialogue between Hugo Munsterberg and John Henry Wigmore, which scared Munsterberg and other social scientists away from the courts for most of the last century, on the grounds that more data and more research were necessary before the social sciences were ready for the rigors of a well-crafted cross-examination. Now, the studies have been done, the science is in, and Reno and others see this conference as an opportunity to make new efforts at bringing science and the law more closely into alignment.

Jeremy Travis, former director of the National Institute of Justice, told the story of receiving a call from Janet Reno when she was the US Attorney General under Clinton. She was reading an article in the Washington Post about a man who had just been released from prison after 10 years of wrongful conviction, which was overturned by way DNA test results that cleared him from involvement. That story led Ms. Reno to investigate how many other cases there were like this one, and then to root out the causes. That investigation led to the study published as "Convicted by Juries, Exonerated by Science," (PDF) which told the tale of 26 DNA exonerees, almost all of whom had been convicted based on faulty eyewitness testimony and, ultimately, a failure of science to inform the criminal justice system.

More to come from John Jay in the days ahead.



Read more :: Permalink

Tuesday, February 13, 2007

Reform of Outdated Police Procedures : Smart Policy, Smart Politics

Decades of scientific research shows that a few simple reforms to police procedures -- like recording interrogations and identification procedures, using a "blind" method for conducting a photospread or a lineup (one where the police officer running the procedure doesn't know who the suspect is), being careful about how police instruct witnesses -- can ensure that police catch the real culprit more often, and arrest the wrong guy less often. In other words, police reform is good, smart policy.

Its also good politics. As a state senator in Illinois, Barack Obama was instrumental in reforming police procedures after his state suffered an epidemic of wrongful capital convictions. As a district attorney in Hennipin County, Minnesota, Amy Klobuchar instituted a series of important reforms to eyewitness identification procedures.

Last we checked, Senator Obama and Senator Klobuchar's political fortunes had not suffered as a result of sponsoring these reforms. In fact, they're both stronger than ever.

Cross-posted at Daily Kos



Read more :: Permalink